Book review: Dog Warrior
Mar. 31st, 2007 07:15 pmToday's book review is Dog Warrior by Wen Spencer.
This is the fourth Ukiah Oregon book. (See my reviews of Alien Taste, Tainted Trail, and Bitter Waters.) Don't try to read the series out of order; there's a lot of important background that is only glossed over, like who and what the major characters are.
The plot in this one is getting a little hard to believe. The new character introduced is not impossible by the rules from the previous books, but it's unlikely enough that he'd be just as he is to be a bit of a stretch. And the main villain of the series has a new plot revealed that is a tiny bit contrived. (It is amusing, though, how the evil plot is used as a justification of one of the biggest boondoggles in recent history.) But in spite of the shakiness of the plot, I found the characters and story captivating. Ukiah and the new character end up growing a fair bit emotionally. Unfortunately, the book ends in a rush (perhaps to keep things ambiguous enough that there's room for the series to continue, both on the level of big evil plots and on the level of the characters' personal lives), leaving me less than fully fulfilled about where the story ends.
It sounds like I didn't like the book, for all the complaining I'm doing, but I didn't. My reading was stretched out over too long a time with too much going on in my life, but I found the story comfortable when I managed to find a few minutes to read. For all the weaknesses, I think it's a better book than the previous two, and maybe better than Alien Taste. As long as you bring a fair bit of willingness to suspend disbelief, you can probably enjoy it too. 8 out of 10.
( plot summary )
This is the fourth Ukiah Oregon book. (See my reviews of Alien Taste, Tainted Trail, and Bitter Waters.) Don't try to read the series out of order; there's a lot of important background that is only glossed over, like who and what the major characters are.
The plot in this one is getting a little hard to believe. The new character introduced is not impossible by the rules from the previous books, but it's unlikely enough that he'd be just as he is to be a bit of a stretch. And the main villain of the series has a new plot revealed that is a tiny bit contrived. (It is amusing, though, how the evil plot is used as a justification of one of the biggest boondoggles in recent history.) But in spite of the shakiness of the plot, I found the characters and story captivating. Ukiah and the new character end up growing a fair bit emotionally. Unfortunately, the book ends in a rush (perhaps to keep things ambiguous enough that there's room for the series to continue, both on the level of big evil plots and on the level of the characters' personal lives), leaving me less than fully fulfilled about where the story ends.
It sounds like I didn't like the book, for all the complaining I'm doing, but I didn't. My reading was stretched out over too long a time with too much going on in my life, but I found the story comfortable when I managed to find a few minutes to read. For all the weaknesses, I think it's a better book than the previous two, and maybe better than Alien Taste. As long as you bring a fair bit of willingness to suspend disbelief, you can probably enjoy it too. 8 out of 10.
( plot summary )