tigertoy: (Default)
As I write this, I've piled up a backlog of books to review (because I read while I was sick this week but I didn't review), and I can't connect to the Internet because my phone isn't working.  So I can't really say "today's book review".  Let's say, rather, that my first deferred book review is Eifelheim by Michael Flynn.

This is a standalone novel; from the notes in the book, it was expanded from an award-winning novelette, but the new material is a complete narrative, and the two narratives are interwoven fairly well.  Even if the old material is exactly the same as the earlier publication, well over half of the book is new material, and there's reason to read it (although the really important plot will have been spoiled).

This is harder SF than most of what's being written these days.  We have speculation about physics and cosmology that makes as much scientific sense (to me, anyway) as some stuff I read on news web sites about what the real physicists are up to.  Of course, being a novel, it doesn't have the math, but I wouldn't be able to follow the math if it did.  We also have some interesting, if hard to swallow, speculation about making history into a rigorous discipline, backed up with very timely stuff about the nature of historical research in the age of teh Intarwebz.  The book is mainly about one of the main themes of SF and handles that theme convincingly.  Really, the only thing I don't like is that the part of the story that's set in the past is set in a period that don't really enjoy visiting, and I'll rant about that inside the cut because it's a minor spoiler.

Tons of stuff to think about, and a good enough story that I can definitely recommend it.  9 out of 10.

spoilery commentary and plot summary )
tigertoy: (Default)
Today's book review is Falling Stars by Michael Flynn.

This is the fourth and final book in Flynn's Firestar series, a series that started out with a bang but ended closer to a whimper.  If a near-present-day hard SF series about how we should be exploring space appeals, you definitely should read Firestar if you haven't.  If it leaves you wanting more, keep reading the series, but be warned that the later books have less punch.  If you haven't read the series, don't read it out of order; almost all of the characters are ongoing and you won't really understand the characters in Falling Stars if you don't know where they came from.

The best thing about this book is that Jimmy Poole, who started out as a friendless fat geek in high school and went on to become the leading hacker of the age and a real son of a bitch, actually develops some human decency.  This was comforting because I see a lot of myself in Jimmy Poole.  The worst thing about this book is that the big loose end from Lodestar, the third book, isn't satisfyingly put to bed.  The characters have come up with their own explanation of the puzzle which justifies the way they handle it as the right solution, but we don't get the confirmation that it really *was* the right answer, so we're left wanting to know how things turn out in the world.  However, the state that the characters are left in seems to confirm that this really is the last book in the series:  the ongoing characters have, between them, have had quite a bit of control of worldwide events in the series, but by the end of this book, the world has moved on and to continue the big story would require Flynn to come up with a whole lot of new characters and background.

On its own merits, this isn't a bad book -- it certainly kept me turning pages -- but I really only recommend it as the not-quite-completely-satisfying conclusion to the series.  7 out of 10.

Profile

tigertoy: (Default)
tigertoy

January 2026

S M T W T F S
    12 3
45 678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags